After another tumultuous and exhausting day at back-to-school orientation, I navigated several trains after the orange and yellow line were announced to be malfunctioning. The rainy day crept up on me, and I was drenched by the time I arrived to 14th Street, both in sweat and muddy puddle water. In that moment, all I wanted was good conversation and a sweet treat. Thankfully, Brady and I had agreed to spend an evening hour at Schmackary’s, a specialty shop with a knack for baking batches of cookies, situated just around the corner from New York University.
The colorful storefront and vast glass display of cookies may be overwhelming to some, but exciting to others. Brady and I were thrilled at the prospect of indulging in such a wide selection of flavors, as we both have big sweet tooths and big stomachs. We picked six different cookies, all of which were about as big as Brady’s hand. I also selected a Cinnamon Toast Crunch Rice Krispie treat, which was also rather large in size.
“So so good. Very sweet! It had Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal within the Rice Krispie and a sweet cereal milk glaze holding it together. Nice sweet frosting on top,” Brady gushed. “I wouldn’t normally gravitate toward Rice Krispies, but this was so good. Definitely recommend!”
This extremely chunky and thick treat had whole pieces of cereal and a smooth layer of cinnamon frosting atop. Some of our cookies paired nicely, like the Cookies and Cream, Worms n’ Dirt, Peanut Butter Cup, and Classic chocolate chip.
“The Worms n’ Dirt is super chocalate-y in the best way. The gummy worm on the top was not stale at all, which you might expect from a cookie. Almost better than a normal gummy worm,” Brady observed. “Chocolate lovers will love these.”
I found the Peanut Butter Cup to be the most intriguing, as it was a vegan selection and noted as a fan favorite. This baked good is characterized by its use of dark cocoa, peanut butter, peanut butter chips, and semi sweet chocolate, which create a heavily sweet and salty cookie.
“The Classic chocolate chip cookie [has a] very interesting flavor, a bit different from a normal chocolate chip cookie but it might be for you!” Brady commented. “Cookie and cream [was] probably my favorite of the ones I tasted. The frosting was really delicious and sweet.”
As for the two non-chocolate cookies, we deeply enjoyed the Funfetti and Stay Gold cookies. Schmackary’s swap out the cookies flavors on a monthly basis, with the Classic and the Funfetti as the two core pieces of the establishment. Cookies and Cream typically will be on the menu, except during the winter season, where Red Velvet takes it place.
“The Funfetti cookie [has] super good frosting—it makes me feel very nostalgic. [The] sugar cookie taste is really delicious,” Brady said. “Stay Gold frosting is like eating lemon fruit loops. Cookie itself was good!”
The Stay Gold cookie was my personal favorite, as I love all desserts with a lemon tartiness. Though I did appreciate the custom NYU purple frosting on the Funfetti Cookie for students residing nearby. Both treats were soft, chewy, and sugary. The experience overall was a perfect pick-me-up after such a hectic day back in the city.
Just within walking distance of the NYU campus, Schmackary’s is an excellent choice for students to visit, especially considering the discount they can receive through the Campus Clipper. Eligible students can display the digital coupon below and their valid student ID to claim the deal. Instead of venturing to Insomnia Cookies or Crumbl for overpriced baked goods, New Yorkers are much better off visiting the locale when in need of a delectable sweet treat.
